"Let life enchant you again." - Fernando Gros
0 items in your cart
Blog // Creativity // Productivity
April 16, 2018

Why I Went Back To Paper Planning

Calendar and diary apps are great. But, increasingly, I rely on paper as the best technology for planning my life and work.

Although computers were part of my life from an early age, they didn’t always come with the tools for planning and organising your life: reliable calendar apps didn’t come till later. So, I went through my school years and started my working life using paper planners, diaries and calendars. However, I abandoned those by the late 90s, with a technology-embracing mix of hope and joy. As notebook computers became cheaper and more popular, followed by devices like the palm pilot and, later, the earliest smartphones, it seemed like carrying a big paper diary or planner would become a thing of the past.

So, why have I gone back to using paper to plan out my days? The answer is simple: it is, in so many ways, the best technology.

Living in Japan Made Me Ask the Question

There’s a popular view that Japan, and Tokyo in particular, are some kind of futuristic dream world. As if walking through the streets of Tokyo is like being transported into some alternate sci-fi reality, such as Blade Runner.

Maybe it felt like that 30 years ago.

While there is plenty of Japan-only innovations here, Tokyo doesn’t feel anymore high tech than a lot of other modern Asian cities. If anything, the persistence of older technology, from commonly using fax machines to cassette tapes in local convenience stores, along with the aisles of CDs in music stores, makes it feel less like a sci-fi fan’s fantasy and more like a place less prone to embracing the new because, simply, it is new.

Go to any stationary or office supply store and you see something you might not see in many other countries, shelves upon shelves of personal planners, paper diaries and calendars – not just at new year and not just as a novelty.

At first, I would wonder, why, in a country that’s so synonymous with technological advancement, was this old-school approach to planning and managing time still so popular?

Paper as a Technology

We’re intoxicated with the idea that the solution to life’s problems is technology. But, we seldom stop to ask what we mean by technology. A question which I had upon first reading William Power’s book, Hamlet’s Blackberry, where Powers suggested the surprisingly novel idea that we think of paper as a technology. After all, it was new once: it was once a solution to exiting problems and a replacement for old ways of recoding information. The evolution of paper as a material and the marking of paper—from pens, to hand printing, to industrialised print—is as much as anything we might say about computers and the internet, it’s a story of technology changing the way we live and work.

So, the proper technological question doesn’t regard itself with what shiny new device or app is the best solution for your problem. Rather, it asks which technology—from a range of technologies, of which paper and pen might be one of the options—is the best solution.

Paper is a technology. So, the opposites aren’t paper and technology: it’s paper and computers. And, both are technologies with pros and cons to consider.

An extreme example of this is found in the planner and diary aisles of many Japanese office and stationary stores. In amongst the 12-month, 18-month, three-year, ten-year, school, work, domestic-life and gardening planners are the end-of-life planners. These, often detailed diaries, look, at first, like a standard planner, but the categories and sections are specifically tailored to someone “getting their affairs in order”. From sections for funeral arrangements to mapping out banking, legal and investment details, there is even space for life lessons and memorable moments.

It stops you with shock, but it also feels apt. In stark contrast to many western countries, you realise that older people, seniors and pensioners are to adapt to digital technology to manage their banking, social security and other personal matters.

Having Technology that Respects Seasonality

When most digital experiences play out now, we just scroll infinitely through a bottomless page. Digital calendars increasingly give us the same design.

But, life is not an infinite scroll. Life has seasons, beginnings and endings, and we choose to mark those with rituals, ceremonies, birthdays anniversaries and other commemorations.

It’s perhaps no wonder that we suffer so much in heart and mind, when the technology we rely on disconnects us from the natural rhythms of life – rhythms which ought to slow us down us and invite us to connect with the people and places around us, and reflect on what our lives mean.

How I Plan My Working Year or the Rule of 1+4×3

Last year, I reconfigured my business here in Japan, part of moving away from freelance work. To help with this, I did the Tara Gentile’s Goal-Setting and Planning course on Creative Live. Courses, like this, can be a great substitute, if you don’t have a collaborator or coach to help push you to dig a little deeper.

One insight from the course is something I’ve taken to calling the Rule of 1+4×3. Gentile’s suggestion is to give your business one big goal for the year (the 1), something that will organise and give a sense of mission to everything you do. Then, pick 3-5 projects per quarter (the 4×3) that will help you achieve that goal.

And, yes, 1+4×3 equals 13: don’t think about that, the metaphor is not that precise.

What it did for me last year was actually limit, in a fairly radical way, the number of projects I undertook. It also gave me one of the best years I’ve had in a long time, when it comes to actually getting shit done!

The planner I chose for the year, which I started using when I was doing the course, is the U-Line Four Seasons from Jiyu-Style. Rather than one notebook for the year, it come as four seasonal books.

In each quarterly book, you get the quarter laid out in both weeks and days. The week spreads out over two pages, and this gives an instant glimpse of the week. No matter the app or programme, I’ve always felt like it’s a struggle to get a digital calendar to look anywhere near as good as a well laid out paper one. In a way, digital calendars feel dumb – having to click, then tell it what I want, how long, etc.

Aiming a pen at paper is still the most intuitive technology I know of for this task.

The layout also gives me one-page per day. This is a stark contrast to digital apps where you can just keep adding things to your to-do list forever. One page is like a natural barrier to over committing yourself. There’s something about having to write down what you plan to do in a day that suddenly makes you ask, “can I really get through all this?” Virtual to-do lists are so weightless: it’s easy to create lists that are so long and so full of challenging actions and projects, and it might take several lifetimes to do them all well.

There’s also something wonderfully satisfying in looking at a full page at the end of the day, reflecting on what got done, deciding what to transfer to another day or what to approach differently in the future, without an infinite ghost of commitments looming in some digital cupboard.

I still use iCal for appointments at outside locations. Having a Google Maps link, together with the contact details for the person I’m meeting, embedded in the calendar is very helpful. For this, digital is a better technology.

But, for running my day, for keeping track of how well I’m doing and where plans need to be adjusted and for reflecting on how it all went and where I want to go tomorrow, paper is best.

The Simple Conclusion

Adding a paper planner to my life, initially, felt like an inconvenience. One more thing to worry about and carry around. But, I can jot things down on paper far easier than on an iPhone, without having to worry about how much battery I have left. I can easily see my week at a glance, or transfer things I didn’t finish today to tomorrow.

It’s an addition that simplifies and calms, it doesn’t invite distraction or allow me to overcommit by adding too many things to my schedule. I wish I’d made this change sooner.

Agostina 6 years ago

The Jiyu seasonal calendar looks so simple and beautiful in a very delicate way. Choosing the right calendar or planner for each year is something I always love doing, although sometimes its hard to find “the right one”.

What you see while writing down a list of tasks does help to either look forward to those tasks or could just make them feel like a burden. Its also a nice way to “store” memories with a nicer and more romantic surrounding.

Dane Cobain 6 years ago

I’ve tried planning both by hand and with computer software and I’ve always found that planning on paper works best. Maybe it takes a little longer, especially because if you plan on paper then you’re going to want to type it up or scan it in so that you have a digital backup, but it also helps you to think things out and to visualise things properly.

There was a study a little while back that found that students who took notes by hand remembered more than those who took notes on a laptop or a tablet computer: https://www.psychologicalscience.org/index.php/news/were-only-human/ink-on-paper-some-notes-on-note-taking.html

I think that kind of shows how planning on paper can help you to absorb more of what you’re actually planning. I suppose it depends on what you’re planning and why – if you’re in a rush and you just need to get it done, a computer will do. If you have a little time and you want to get it just right, go with paper planning.

I should point out as well that I write books, and I plan those books by hand on paper and then write the first draft at a computer. So I guess that shows where I stand!

Jorge 6 years ago

The 1+4×3 method sounds really achievable, when you split a big goal in smaller tasks, it actually seems doable and not this huge mountain you are trying to climb without sherpas (and 13 is my lucky number, I’ll take that as a sign). Im going to try to give it a go this year, even if its almost May already…

Agostina 6 years ago

Really nice article, Dane Cobain, Ive always had to write everything by hand while studying for exams because it was the only true way my brain could record it and process it, and ultimately, really learn the concepts. Thought it was more of a personal choice/way the brain works than a general thing. Nice to find out there is a study about it.

fernando 6 years ago

Agostina – yes! Going through my planner from last year reminded me of a trip to Hong Kong I’d taken and had almost forgotten! Was wonderful to look at sketches and notes. For some reason I wrote “blogging as an epic adventure” in bold on one of the pages. Can’t remember why, but it’s a wonderful thought.

Carla 6 years ago

I run out of battery a lot (silly forgetful me… and my phone broke down now!) so I tend to write down on a piece of paper the number of the person im meeting and the address just in case my phone dies on the way there. Paper will always be more reliable to me.

Mats 6 years ago

I do enjoy how Google Calendar in a 1984 style observes my digital movements and tells me I should get going to the airport in half an hour if I want to make it even if I didnt put it on the calendar myself, creepy but effective.

fernando 6 years ago

Mats – the overlord mode of digital calendars is pretty scary!

fernando 6 years ago

Jorge – yes, there’s always time left in the year to make things count!

fernando 6 years ago

Carla – yes, I’ve been known to stare in disbelief at my phone when the screen goes dark on an important list I needed for a meeting or shopping trip.

fernando 6 years ago

Dane – great article, thank you. And yes, the testimony of an author on planning with paper counts for a lot!

Robin 6 years ago

Paper planners work best for me as I can easily keep track of tasks I have accomplished and those that need to be carried forward.

When using my device, I find that I get easily distracted by other apps reducing my productive time.

I haven’t planned for an entire year, looking try that out using the rule of 1+4×3 🙂

fernando 6 years ago

Robin – yes, I love the mono tasking thing when planning with paper. Turn the page and there’s more paper, not twitter, the news, etc.

Enter your and your to join the mailing list.